TheTechLawyer's Blog
  • Home
Big Tech

The changing landscape of Technology laws

by dinkar kalra June 23, 2021
written by dinkar kalra

It is a long accepted fact that laws cannot keep pace with Technology. However, countries around the globe are waking up to the dangers that an under regulated tech industry may present. Better late than never I guess.

The Unites States Congress has proposed five new laws that will help regulators, that are designed to adapt America’s antitrust regulations to meet the challenges raised by big tech and so called ‘free services’. They are :

  1.  The American Innovation and Choice Online Act : this law would make it illegal for online stores to use algorithms that benefit their own products/services or excludes those of others.
  2. The Ending Platform Monopolies Act: this law would allow regulators to block online platforms from owning businesses that could lead to a conflict of interest or would lead to drastically reduced competition in the market. For example, Google owning a company that shows ads on a search engine it owns and owning youtube that competes for front page links with others in search results.
  3. The Platform Competition and Opportunity Act : this law would provide regulators with several more angles to investigate potentially predatory behaviour. This would seek to put an end to the “Copy/Acquire/Kill” tactics that several large companies employ.
  4. The Augmenting Compatibility and Competition by Enabling Service Switching Act : this law would empower users to transfer their data from one platform to another making it easier for users to switch service providers. (a benefit that EU users already enjoy under GDPR, but this would be a little more detailed and seeks to set standards for interoperability)
  5. The Merger Filing Fee Modernization Act : this law would make it a lot more expensive for large companies to file for mergers and just use that money to beef the antitrust regulators.

The EU is holding consultations with stakeholders over the provisions of the proposed Digital Services Act and the Digital Markets Act and a new e-Privacy Regulation (to update the e-Privacy directive)

The Digital Services Act seeks to ensure:

  1. A single set of rules for the EU to keep users safe online and to protect their freedom of expression
  2. That internet companies prioritise complaints raised by “trusted flaggers”, who have a track record of highlighting valid problems.
  3. All online stores must be able to trace traders selling goods via their platforms, in case they are offering counterfeit items or other illegal products by verifying their identity
  4. An annual independent audit of tech companies to ensure compliance.
  5. That tech companies publish a report into their handling of major risks, including users posting illegal content, disinformation that could sway elections, and the unjustified targeting of minority groups.

The Digital Markets Act seeks to ensure that big Tech companies do not gain unfair advantage due to their established position.

The new rules include obligations to:

  1. Inform the regulator of any planned takeover of another service
  2. Not treat their own service more favourably than rivals’ when deciding which order to show them on screen
  3. Not use data gathered via their main service to launch a product that will compete with other established businesses
  4. Let users uninstall pre-installed apps on their platform and use different software

These new laws would empower the European commission to issue fines of up to 10% of a firm’s annual turnover in Europe under the Digital Services Act, and 6% under the Digital Markets Act.

Countries on both sides of the Atlantic are also conducting #Antitrust investigations into Big Tech (most notably Google and Apple).

Meanwhile India still has not passed the proposed Personal Data Protection Bill (which though far from perfect would be a step in the right direction) and has to face the embarrassment of having the new Information Technology (Intermediary Guidelines and Digital Media Ethics Code) Rules, 2021 be widely criticised, both at home and internationally for being violative of the principles of free speech as well as being challenged in Court (where they should quite likely be struck down) . However, giving credit where credit is due, the Competition Commission of India (CCI ) is actively probing several big tech companies for indulging in anti competitive practices.

June 23, 2021 0 comment
1 FacebookTwitterPinterestEmail
Privacy & Data Protection

Do you truly own your health data ?

by dinkar kalra June 20, 2021
written by dinkar kalra

The #NHS‘s attempt to put all medical records in #England on a central database has come in for heavy criticism by medical practitioners and privacy advocates alike. The record seeks to include a person’s entire medical history, from the time of their birth to the time of their death,  their physical, mental and sexual health, including their health-related concerns with family and work and any drug / alcohol history. The data will be used to inform and develop health and social care policy, plan and commission health and care services, take steps to protect public health such as managing the Covid-19 pandemic, enable research, and provide individual care in exceptional cases. The primary concern around this database is that its contents will be made available to the private sector and other researchers and the data will only be ‘#pseudonymised‘ and not ‘#anonymised‘. As any privacy advocate will tell you, given enough data points pseudonymisation can be reversed and data can be connected to an individual. Further, the proposed database will contain the details of the medical professionals who treat each patient. Information on the surgery or hospital to which they’re attached is freely available online, so by following one line of data it’s possible to narrow down potential patients from the entire population of 60 million to one in a few thousand. Also it does not help that the NHS has had a very dodgy record of keeping patient data private (data was released to Google Deep Mind in 2015 and to pharmaceutical companies in 2019)

Ironically, the new scheme has been named the General Practice Data for Planning and Research (or the ‘GPDPR’ if you will) and seems to work contrary to the basic principle of individuals owning their own data under the ‘GDPR’. It is also necessary to point out that this scheme was in development for three years but patients were given just over a month to be made aware of the project and opt out if they wished to do so. This isn’t even the first time the NHS has tried something like this. In 2014, the Care.data initiative was proposed, with the objective of sharing patient data with external organisations which was reversed after massive public outcry.

In #India as well the Government is going full steam ahead on the implementation of the National Digital Health Mission (#NDHM) that seeks to create a single repository of medical records of all citizens. However, unlike #Aadhaar, the data will reside at individual hospital servers and citizens will supposedly own their health data and any data sharing would be through the medium of a government entity and would require consent of the individual. However, details on the scheme are scarce and it cannot be said what level of access the government will have to this data, what security protocols will be put in place and how this extremely sensitive data will be protected from abuse. There has been no mention of an opt out provision.

June 20, 2021 0 comment
0 FacebookTwitterPinterestEmail
Privacy & Data Protection

Are Privacy Policies the cure to Insomnia ?

by dinkar kalra June 19, 2021
written by dinkar kalra

Facebook’s Data Privacy policy is 10 pages long (4242 words), add to that another 3 pages of the Cookie policy (2157 words using a teeny tiny font size of 8 or 9) and you have a total of 13 pages (6399 words). However, it needs to be mentioned that Facebook does provide a Privacy checkup tool with some limited functionality. Instagram uses the same policies but provides no counterpart to the Privacy checkup tool.

Twitter’s Privacy policy is 19 pages long (5391 words), although in all fairness they have used a large font and left wide margins in the document. Twitter also provides a reasonable 1 page summary.

As expected Google’s privacy policy is the largest, coming in at a massive 28 pages (7420 words). Again, it needs to be pointed that the document uses double spacing and wide margins with clearly laid out headings, there are even some useful videos to help users. However, to get a complete picture of the Privacy settings a user would also have to go through how Google employs various technologies at its disposal (cookies, location information, pattern recognition, google voice etc.) which adds to the already sizeable privacy policy.

If we could bottle these, I am sure they would be a great cure for Insomnia!! Jokes apart, we need an easier system than this quite frankly soporific exercise. Layered notices are all well and good but its about time that there were international privacy certifications that could tell us whatever we need in one glance.

Facebook’s Data Privacy policy is available at https://www.facebook.com/about/privacy/update/printable and the cookie policy at https://www.facebook.com/policy/cookies/printable. Instagram’s data policy is available at https://help.instagram.com/519522125107875 and the cookie policy at https://help.instagram.com/1896641480634370/?helpref=hc_fnav&bc[0]=Instagram%20Help&bc[1]=Policies%20and%20Reporting.

Twitter’s privacy policy is available at https://twitter.com/en/privacy#:~:text=Twitter%20is%20public%20and%20Tweets,not%20to%20use%20your%20name.

Google’s privacy policy is available at https://policies.google.com/privacy?hl=en-US.

June 19, 2021 0 comment
0 FacebookTwitterPinterestEmail

Recent Posts

  • The changing landscape of Technology laws
  • Do you truly own your health data ?
  • Are Privacy Policies the cure to Insomnia ?

Recent Comments

    • Facebook
    • Twitter
    • Linkedin

    @2021 - All Right Reserved. Designed and Developed by Dinkar Kalra


    Back To Top
    TheTechLawyer's Blog
    • Home